How to play music by ear?

I remember as a child watching a news program about a kid — probably a teen — who was a musical prodigy, playing all sorts of music on the piano by ear. I was amazed. I was taking piano lessons, learning to play piano painstakingly by reading the music. I wanted to play piano with facility — but what that kid could do was like a magical musical gift — and I didn’t have any “gift” like that! I did not believe that there was any way possibly for me to learn to do what he did.

A lot of decades have passed since then. I have a degree in music. I consider myself a musician. I have, in the ensuring years, met a few individuals who can play piano very well, even some who can play by ear, like that kid. I am primarily a singer, and while I don’t play piano like that kid in the news program, I can play piano sufficiently well and I can play piano by ear. It is not “magic” — it is a skill that any hearing person with some experience on an musical instrument can learn.

Music has structure — most of the time, we hear the structure, find beauty in the structure, but most people do not recognize and track the structure without some instruction in how to do so. (A few people — like the kid in the news program — notice and track the structure of music without being taught. They often play music by ear and sometimes learn to play musical instruments with little to no formal instruction. This is not all that odd when one considers that music is very similar to language, and human minds are wired for language acquisition.) Music instructors usually teach something about the structure of music to their students — but, very often, the structure that is taught is missing the components that tie it into what we hear. (This may be because the music instructor was never taught to recognize musical structures by how they sound and so does not know how to teach this.) The instruction that is given focuses on written notes or chords on the page or hand placement on an instrument without connecting those elements to the characteristics of the sound being created.

Learning to play an instrument by ear means that, in addition to learning to read notes, chords and scales, and how to place fingers, one learns to hear and recognize the sound patterns of chord progressions and common passages of notes. Instead of, for example, playing a piece of written music for the first time and then afterwards commenting about how nice it sounded, the musician can look at the notes and imagine how it sounds, because a strong understanding exists between the written notes and the sounds they represent. Or, a musician can hear a passage of notes, find the notes on the instrument, and play them because they fit recognizable aural patterns.

This is also why so many who play musical instruments feel “lost” without a book in front of them supplying notes and/or chords. Without the written book they hear the music, they know how it is supposed to sound, but they do not know how to match the notes and chords of their instrument to what they hear.

Here are a couple of beginning exercises for learning to playing music by ear:

Chords –

  • Learn chords by pairs. The pairs would generally be major chords from the same (major) scale that are five degrees apart. So, from the C major scale, C major and G major. From the G major scale, G major and D major. Understand that the chord that shares a name with the scale is the “one chord” (I), and the other chord is the “five chord” (V) for that scale. (In the C major scale, C is I, and G is V. In the G major scale, G is I, and D is V.)
  • Choose a “two-chord song.” Almost all two-chord songs use a chord pattern — called a “chord progression” — that involves the I and V chords. There is a list of common I-V two-chord songs below.
  • Prepare to play the two-chord song by playing the I and V chords back and forth, always starting and ending with I. (So, for the C major scale, play C-G-C; for the G major scale, play G-D-G.)
  • Sing the song or listen to a recording of the song. There is one caveat about listening to a recording of the song — the recording needs to be in the same “key” or scale that you have chosen for two chords. It will be difficult (but not impossible) to listen to a recording in one key and then play the song on your instrument in a different key.
  • Once you have the song clearly in your mind from reviewing it, and the chords clearly in your minds and in your hands on your instrument, you are ready to experiment with playing by ear. Play the I chord. Start singing the song as you play the chord, or, you can start the recording of your song. Continue to play the I chord until it doesn’t sound “just right” any longer — when that happens, switch to the V chord. Keep switching whenever the chord does not seem to fit the melody or the recording.

Melody –

  • First, you need to be familiar with the notes of at least one scale on your instrument. On a piano, this could be a C major scale. Often, on a guitar, students will start with a G major scale. A clarinet or trumpet would likely start with Bb major. Play up the scale from note 1 through 7, then 8, and go back down to 1, listening as you play.
  • Select a song to sing or a recording to listen to — if it is a recording, the key or scale of the recording needs to match the scale that you are familiar with on your instrument.
  • Play note 1 of your scale several times. It will be the note that shares the name of the scale, for example, in C major, note number 1 would be C, in G major it would be G, in Bb major it would be Bb. Then, “set the key”: play note 1, then note 3, note 5, then jump back to note 1. (There are many ways to “set the key,” this is just one of the simplest.)
  • Start singing your song or play the recording. Play note 1 softly on your instrument and listen for when the melody of the song is also on note 1. When the melody is also on note 1, play note 1 strongly. After a while, you will likely notice that it becomes easier to “predict” or have a sense about when the melody is approaching note 1. Note 1 is often called the “home” note of a scale — in music, we also call this sense of home “tonic.”

Two-chord songs (I-V)

  • There was an old woman who swallowed a fly
  • Jambalaya
  • Skip to my lou
  • The eency weency spider
  • How much is that doggie in the window
  • Shoo fly, don’t bother me

Alisa Phoenix | Alisa Phoenix, The Phoenician Muse, on YouTube | Phoenix Tech Gurus | The Phoenician Muse on Substack | The Automatic Earth | Igor the Jazz Cowboy | Sunnyslope Historical Society | Alisa Moore |